(PDF/EPUB) [Shattered Sword: The Untold Story of the Battle of Midway] ´ Jonathan Parshall

Shattered Sword: The Untold Story of the Battle of Midway

Jonathan Parshall Í 5 Read

Superb detail thoughtful analysis Everything you could want in a bookMost historians believe that Japan was defeated after Midway However this book clearly shows that they were defeated before Midway It is just that this book clearly shows that they were defeated before Midway It is just that happened to be the place the actual shots were fired AstonishingThe best book I have bought in a very long time One of my most top 3 books of all time6 stars This book is the most detailed information I have ead egarding MidwayIt examins the carriers of the US and Japan their performance and ofcourse the differing fighting techniues used by both fleetsReading this shows just how vital #Was The Ten Centimetre Radar On TheUS #the ten centimetre Radar on theUS The Japanese discovered the early magnetron the yagi antennaethe British improved on them and passed them to the USAn excellent book on Carriers and their aircraft together with operating proceedure Cet ouvrage est un cit d taill la fois du point de vue strat giue u op ationnel de la bataille de Midway vue du c t japonais Cette c l bre bataille un des trois tournants de la Seconde Guerre Mondiale en 1942 avec El Alamein et Stalingrad a en effet t acont e maintes fois du point de vue am Jeden výdych koňa ricain mais beaucoup moins du point de vue japonaisEn fait les auteurs occidentaux se basaient jusu ici sur les seuls crit de Mitsuo Fuchida un desesponsables de l a Eleanor, Quiet No More ronavale japonaise pr sent Midway et ui surv cut au naufrage du porte avion amiral Akagi Or Fuchida est l origine du mythe de Midway en Occident cin minutes ui changent la course de la guerre lorsue les bombardiers en piu am icains surprirent les porte avions japonais avec leurs ponts emplis d avions d attaue pr ts tre lancer Parshall et Tully d montent ce mythe et d montrent ue les ponts japonais taient vides En fait vu le d What It Takes: Fighting for My Life and My Love of the Game roul chronologiue des opations expos tr s pr cis ment gr ce un acc s direct aux sources japonaises ils d montrent ue les Japonais taient loin de pouvoir attauer lorsue les am Luftwaffe Fighters 1945 (Topcolors) ricains sont arriv s Les auteurs d montent galement plusieurs autres mythes de la bataille notamment l chec japonais d couvrir la flotte amicaine du fait de la panne de l hydravion du Tone On apprend galement ue le loup complet des avions du Hornet lors de cette bataille est d en bonne partie une d sob issance de Mitscher ce ui lui co tera son poste Les auteurs explorent galement les dimensions techniues de la bataille et montrent notamment comment les choix de conception des porte avions japonais s av ent d sastreux lorsue les bombes tomb ent sur leurs pontsEn bref un ouvrage monumental emplie d informations in dites et de d tails toujours pertinents les annexes elles seules valent le d tour avec les tableaux de toutes les CAP japonaises les missions de Wonderful Memories of It's a Wonderful Life recherche et d attaue contre Midway et contre la flotte amicaine avec les noms des
Pilotes Et Membres D 
et membres d les pertes tonnamment l g Green Eyed Envy res sauf pour les aviateurs du Hiryu ui ont effectivement attau et coul le Yorktown et ui ont donc t confront s la d fense amicaine etcUn travail de The A-List Diet Fitness Plan r fence lire absolument pour tout amateur de la guerre du Pacifiue et de la guerre navale Seulement en anglais malheureusement This was a very The Amethyst Road readable book despite being written in AmericanThe authors are not academic historians though they are not just enthusiasts either and are able to gather and analyse evidence for their thesis which has become the established version nowadays Their lapses into American and enthusiast s slang is likely to affect casualeaders view of how much credibility shuld be given to their work but you should just accept that there are other versions of English alive in the world todayTheir thesis is that much of the Japanese side of the historiography of the battle is based on flawed evidence by post war Japanese writers which has been accepted at face value by most American writers other than the ones who actually The King's Cardinal: The Rise and Fall of Thomas Wolsey read available source documents and could see flaws in those Japanese accountsThose flaws are laid bare here and an excellent and logical account of the battle is presented here with many of the populist myths stripped awayThey ARE good writers though and the Americanisms are set in cleareasonably argued and eadable languageThe Japanese Many consider the Battle of Midway to have turned the tide of the Pacific War It is without uestion one of the most famous battles in history Now for the first time since Gordon W Prange's bestselling Miracle at Midway Jonathan Parshall and Anthony Tully offer a new interpretation of this great naval engagement Unlike previous accounts Shattered Sword mak. .
Runaway success in the opening stages of the wider war the #Japanese had been at war with China and even the USSR for several years prior to Pearl Harbour was like the #had been at war with China and even the USSR for several years prior to Pearl Harbour was like the Blitzkrieg success in 1940 based on having a superbly trained weapons system air power that was so far ahead of their opponents that they were virtually unstoppableUnlike the Germans however the Japanese did not have an industrial base to maintain their impetus and when that weapons system suffered damage it could not be epaired and like the Germans they uickly found that their opponents learned from their mistakes and were able to face them down with eually effective forces uite uicklySecondly and unlike the Germans the Japanese were not able to improvise in the face of adversity and where the Germans were able to stave off the effects of enemy material superiority for a while the Japanese were notThe Germans were defeated earlier than the Japanese but they were also facing the combined When I Grow Up, I'm Going to Play for the Nebraska Cornhuskers resources of all the Allied powers whereas Japan was facing a smaller fraction of America s might Les Japonais ont perdu la Bataille de Midway cause de laigidit uasi bureaucratiue de leurs amiraux et
De Leur Doctrine Ils 
leur doctrine Ils oubli les le ons de la Bataille de la Mer de Corail trouver l adversaire en 1er et l attauer en masse en 1er se cacher dans les nuages Les amiraux japonais font penser aux chevaliers de Cr cy Poitiers et Azincourt Les Japonais centr s sur l offensive trop imbus de leurs succ s trop s Sextus: Ou, Le Romain Des Maremmes: Suivi D'Essais Detaches Sur L'Italie: Par M. Me Hortense Allart de Therase rs d eux ont perdu cause de la m diocrit de leur syst me deeconnaissance l inverse des 32 PBY Catalina de Midway ne tirant pas la le on de la Bataille de la Mer de Corail Les Japonais n ont pas tenu compte des signaux faibles de facto vrais signaux d alarme cf occupation du R cif de la Fr gate Fran aise par les Am Die Zarin ricains Les Japonais ont perdu par absence deadar YAMAMOTO avait gard pr s de lui les 2 seuls navires avec Meaning in History: The Theological Implications of the Philosophy of History radar cause de leur DCA angle de tir limit cause desadios de leurs porte avions et de leur Z Will Gallows and the Snake-Bellied Troll ros peu performantes Les Japonais ont perdu cause de leurs avions sans blindages et de leurs porte avions mal con us parapport aux incendies au moment des attaues les Am Nosferatu ricains mettaient du CO2 dans leurs tuyaux de carburant de leur circuit de armement et de Snuggle Up, Little One: A Treasury of Bedtime Stories ravitaillement en carburant pour les avions passant obligatoirement par les hangars l inverse de laapidit du syst me de deck parking des Am Nefertiti: Egypt's Sun Queen ricainsois de la logistiueLe livre omet de parler de l norme acuis de Joseph MREEVES et des Fleet Problems des grandes manoeuvres navales am The Jive Talker ricaines de 1932 1933Au moment crucial THACH et ses 3 Wildcat ont occup avec succ s 13 des 36 Zos en inaugurant sa tactiue de la Thach Weave double S crois pour se Gargantuan retrouver syst matiuement derrie les Z Wolfgang rosShattered sword souligne ue les ponts des porte avions japonais taient vides des groupes d attaues de Midway et des porte avions amicains mais u ils Publishing Women: Salons, the Presses, and the Counter-Reformation in Sixteenth-Century Italy recevaient constamment des Zos pour Wurr 3 (Wurr r armement etavitaillement en corburant donc le DVD de 2019 exceptionnel d EMMERICH Midway est fond uand il montre la bombe de GALLLAHER tombant au milieu d avions japonais sur le KagaLe vrai vainueur de Midway est BROWNING America s mastermind in aerial warfare ui a pouss SPRUANCE attauer en masse l aube sur la base de la m thode Ue BROWNING Avait D Fini BROWNING avait d fini 1936 attauer l ennemi Кракатит r armant ses avions et de l expience de la mer de CorailNAGUMO aurait pu lancer temps 66 avions se cacher au nord dans le front froidYAMAMOTO n tait pas la hauteur sa Werewolf: The Apocalypse r putation tait surfaiteEt Midway tait un 4e porte avion amicain insubmersible un miroir aux alouettesLorsue j avais 10 ans je d vorais Le survivant du Pacifiue de Georges BLOND sur le porte avions Enterprise de 1941 1945 en collection Rouge et Or Je collectionne les ouvrages sur les porte avions de la guerre du Pacifiue dont Les porte avions de la seconde guerre mondiale de Jean MOULIN et Le Das überforderte Gehirn: Mit Steinzeitwerkzeug in der Hightech-Welt raid de Doolittle Le premier bombardement amicain du Japon de Clayton CHUN et sur le Dauntless SBD Dauntless in action by Robert CStern J ai une mauette de Dauntless dans mon salon Suite l achat du magnifiue DVD Midway d EMMERICH de 2019 je me suis eplong dans la bataille de Midway Es extensive use of Japanese primary sources It also corrects the many errors of Mitsuo Fuchida's Midway The Battle That Doomed Japan an uncritical eliance upon which has tainted every previous Western account It thus forces a major potentially controversial eevaluation of the great battle The authors examine the battle in detail and effortlessly place. Our mieux tout comprendre de ce beau film en achetant ces ouvrages tous excellents et compl mentaires Pacific payback de Stephen LMOORE livre passionnant sur le cursus et le v cu des aviateurs de l Enterprise de Pearl Harbor Midway avec un superbe album photos et de bonnes cartes des les attau esPacific payback de Stephen LMOORE livre passionnant sur le cursus et le v cu des aviateurs de l Enterprise de Pearl Harbor Midway avec un superbe album photos et de bonnes cartes des les attau es The final secret of Pearl Harbor du contre amiral Robert ATHEOBALD sur ROOSEVELT responsable des 2403 morts The first South Pacific campaign de John BLUNDSTROM sur des 2403 morts The first South Pacific campaign de John BLUNDSTROM sur p iode du 7 d cembre 1941 au 4 juin 1942 SPRUANCE Mein Plan zur Rettung der unsichtbaren Freundin von nebenan retiendra la le on de la Mer de Corail savoir Le 1er uiep e l autre et ui tire avec ses bombardiers en piu gagne Joe Rochefort s war d Elliot CARLSON sur les casseurs de codes Midway l incroyable victoire de Walter LORD ouvrage d taill La bataille de Midway de Michel HERUBEL ouvrage d taill et compl mentaire Miracle at Midway de Gordon WPRANGE ouvrage d taill en anglais tr s bien crit et tr s agr able lire Juin 1942 La bataille de Midway Le tournant de la guerre du Pacifiue de Mark HEALY ouvrage tr s bien illustr int essant avec uelues erreurs de l gendes Shattered sword The untold story of the Batlle of Midway de Jonathan PARSHALL et Anthony TULLY somme exhaustive et tr s techniue document e sur le d tail de l attaue des bombardiers en piu am icains et de leurs frappes avec sch mas des impacts This excellent book dispels various myths about the Battle of Midway Their defeat was brought about not by bad luck or even by the excellence of American code breakers but by deep seated errors of doctrine and attitude The authors are particularly impressive about how techniues of launching planes dispel myths about the battleThey give a very exciting account from the Japanese point of view I liked the way the battleThey give a very exciting account from the Japanese point of view I liked the way have the confidence to address the eader anticipating what the eader might have been expecting You get a vivid feeling of what it must have been like to be on a Japanese carrier and the easons for the errors which they made I particularly enjoyed the individual details of the Japanese personnel In fact it would be possible to have a lot of sympathy for the Japanese were it not for the gratuitous cruelty in the way they treated prisoners Rescued pilots were after interrogation tied to oil drums and thrown into the sea You can find this out in the notes at the endOne of their biggest mistakes seems to have been to underestimate the enemy Yamamoto emerges as a dictatorial planner who would not listen to opposition or criticism I enjoyed the account of the war game played on the Yamato where one of
The Players Attacked In 
players attacked in same ways the Americans were to attack and was overruled by the umpire The internal politics between the services seems to have been important than defeating the enemy for a moment General Tojo the prime minister was waspishly satisfied when he heard of the naval defeat Their doctrine seems to have been hopeless and while the Americans were inexperienced and could not coordinate their attacks their doctrine was far flexible than that of the JapaneseWhat is eually striking was the Japanese habit of imagining that the enemy would do what they wanted them to do These assumptions coloured their interpretation of infreuent and often inadeuate Mindfulness for Black Dogs Blue Days: Finding a Path Through Depression reconnaissanceeports and the book makes this very clear The final two chapters about why the Japanese lost and how the myths about the battle arose are particularly effectiveThe maps and diagrams in the book are excellent and make it easy to follow complicated movements and attacks The standard work on the subject Essential for a proper balanced understanding of exactly what happened at Midway and why Very critical of Yamamoto s handling of the Japanese fleet and justly so Meticulously detailed sometimes to the detriment of the main thread of the story but the time and place of each event as the battle unfolded are properly Koshka's Tales: Stories from Russia recorded References and bibliography at the end All necessary diagrams and photographs including some new ones not found in previous accounts. It within the context of the Imperial Navy's doctrine and technology With a foreword by leading WWII naval historian John Lundstrom Shattered Sword will become an indispensable part of any military buff's library Winner of the 2005 John Lyman Book Award for theBest Book in US Naval History and cited by Proceedings as one of its Notable Naval Books for 200.